When it comes to publishing a high-quality crochet pattern, two key processes come into play: crochet tech editing and pattern testing. While these terms are sometimes used interchangeably, they serve very different purposes in the pattern development process. Both contribute to the overall accuracy and usability of the pattern, but they do so in different ways.

In this blog post, I’ll break down the differences between crochet tech editing and pattern testing, and explain why both are crucial for producing professional patterns.

What is Crochet Tech Editing?

Crochet tech editing is a professional review of the technical aspects of a pattern. A crochet tech editor is responsible for ensuring that the pattern is free from errors, clear, and consistent. Their focus is on the written instructions, math, and formatting, ensuring the pattern works technically, even before anyone picks up a hook to try it. A crochet tech editor may work a small sample to test instructions for clarity but they do not make the full item.

What is Pattern Testing?

Pattern testing involves crocheters working through the pattern and providing feedback to the designer based on their experience. Testers follow the instructions exactly as written to see if they can complete the project without confusion or issues. While pattern testing focuses on how the pattern works in practice, it can also reveal areas where instructions may be unclear or need further refinement.

Key Differences Between Crochet Tech Editing and Pattern Testing

Both crochet tech editing and pattern testing play vital roles in the pattern development process. However, they differ in several key ways:

Focus on Accuracy vs. Usability

Tech Editing: Tech editors focus on the technical accuracy of a pattern. They check for errors in stitch counts, calculations, and measurements. They ensure that every stitch, row, and round aligns with the intended design and that the pattern follows standard conventions.

Pattern Testing: Testers focus on the usability of a pattern. They test whether the instructions are easy to follow and whether the final project matches the designer’s vision. Pattern testing also checks for practical issues, such as yarn recommendations or sizing.

When They Are Involved

Tech Editing:  Tech editors are usually involved early in the pattern development process, before the pattern is sent out to testers. They review the pattern in its draft form to catch technical issues that could prevent it from being accurately followed.

Pattern Testing:  Pattern testers are brought in after the tech editor has reviewed the pattern. Once the technical elements are corrected, testers work through the pattern to ensure that it makes sense in practice and that crocheters of different skill levels can follow it.

Type of Feedback

Tech Editing:  The feedback from a tech editor is usually highly detailed and focused on corrections. They’ll point out issues such as inconsistent terminology, incorrect stitch counts, and unclear instructions. They may also make suggestions for improving the pattern’s clarity and flow.

Pattern Testing:  Testers provide feedback on their experience following the pattern. They may highlight areas that were confusing or difficult, offer suggestions for making the pattern more user-friendly, or report if the finished project didn’t turn out as expected. They often provide photos of their finished projects, which can be helpful for designers and other crocheters.

Scope of Work

Tech Editing:  A tech editor’s role is more technical. They focus on the structure of the pattern, ensuring the math, stitch instructions, and pattern formatting are correct. They check for things like:

•   Accurate stitch counts
•   Correct measurements and gauge
•   Consistent terminology
•   Clear and concise instructions

Pattern Testing:  Testers work through the pattern and provide feedback on how it worked in practice. They check things like:

•   Whether the pattern instructions were clear and easy to follow
•   If the project turned out as expected in terms of size and fit
•   Whether the yarn recommendations and hook size produced the desired result
•   Any general suggestions for improvement

Level of Expertise

Tech Editing:  Tech editors are professionals with specialised knowledge in crochet pattern writing and technical elements. They often have experience in grading patterns, creating schematics, and understanding complex stitch constructions.

Pattern Testing:  Testers are typically skilled crocheters but don’t need to have technical editing skills. Testers are chosen based on their ability to follow instructions and provide feedback on how the pattern works for them.

Why You Need Both Tech Editing and Pattern Testing

While crochet tech editing and pattern testing offer different types of feedback, both are necessary to produce a high-quality crochet pattern.

Here’s why you shouldn’t skip either step:

Tech Editing Ensures Accuracy

Tech editors catch errors that could make the pattern impossible to follow. Without tech editing, mistakes like miscalculated stitch counts or inconsistent terminology could frustrate crocheters and lead to negative reviews.

Pattern Testing Ensures Usability

Pattern testers give you real-world feedback on how the pattern works. They help you understand whether your instructions are clear and if your design produces the intended result. Pattern testers also provide insight into how different yarns or hook sizes affect the final project.

FAQs About Crochet Tech Editing and Pattern Testing

Do I need to hire both a tech editor and pattern testers?  

Yes! Both tech editing and pattern testing are essential. Tech editors ensure the technical elements of your pattern are correct, while testers provide practical feedback based on their experience following the pattern.

Can tech editors also be pattern testers?  

While some tech editors may offer pattern testing as a separate service, it’s best to keep the roles separate. Tech editors focus on the technical side, while testers provide user-focused feedback.

Which comes first, tech editing or pattern testing?  

Tech editing should come first. The tech editor ensures that the pattern is correct and ready for testers. Sending an unedited pattern to testers can lead to confusion and extra rounds of revision.

Final Thoughts on Crochet Tech Editing vs. Pattern Testing

Crochet tech editing and pattern testing are both critical steps in the pattern development process. While tech editors ensure the technical accuracy of your pattern, testers provide valuable feedback on usability. By working with both a tech editor and a group of testers, you can ensure that your pattern is not only correct but also enjoyable to follow. Each process contributes to creating a polished, professional pattern that crocheters will love.

Looking for expert crochet tech editing or pattern testing services? Contact me today to learn more about how we can help perfect your patterns from start to finish! I offer a free 30min Zoom to all new clients, simply book directly into my calendar below.