(Paperback) WHAT HAPPENED TO ME?: Exploring the Mary Theresa Simpson Cold Case

On Sunday, March 15, 1964, twelve-year-old Mary Theresa Simpson vanished after leaving her cousins and aunt outside a neighborhood store in Elmira, New York. Just four days later, her body was discovered on Combs Hill Road.

More than half a century later, the case remains unsolved. The Elmira City Police Department continues to investigate, but questions still linger: What really happened to Mary Theresa? Who was responsible for her disappearance and murder?

In What Happened to Me?, Christina Fanelli blends true crime storytelling with factual research to re-examine this haunting cold case. Through detailed accounts, compelling narrative, and historical context, she sheds light on one of Elmira’s darkest mysteries a tragedy that continues to weigh heavily on the community and the families forever changed by it.

If you’re drawn to true crime books, unsolved mysteries, or cold cases, What Happened to Me? offers a powerful and thought-provoking journey into the unanswered questions surrounding the life and death of Mary Theresa Simpson.