My interest in this subject isn’t rooted in personal nostalgia for the books. It’s rooted in fidelity to literature — in respecting a created world as it actually exists, rather than dragging modern sensibilities into a place where they do not belong.
There are already faithful adaptations of Narnia. The world does not need a new version whose primary impulse is to “fix” or reinterpret Lewis’s cosmology to suit contemporary ideological tastes. Yet that is precisely the direction Greta Gerwig has signaled, both in her public comments and in her casting choices.
In one sense, her honesty is refreshing. She is not pretending to be faithful, and that makes the situation easier to confront directly. But her admission also immediately downgrades the status of this project. If an adaptation openly rejects the worldview, metaphysics, and thematic intent of its source, then it is not truly an adaptation — it is a reinterpretation wearing the name of the original.
Those who care about the actual world of Narnia should treat this film accordingly. It may be a fantasy movie, it may even be a good one, but it is not C.S. Lewis’s Narnia. And labeling it as such misleads audiences about what they are actually being given.
Comments ()